TITLE 329 SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD

SECOND NOTICE OF COMMENT PERIOD

LSA Document #08-209

The Indiana Department of Environmental Management (IDEM or the department) has developed draft rule language for new rules and amendments to rules at 329 IAC 5 concerning implementation of Indiana law regarding environmental impact statements for major state actions that significantly affect the quality of the human environment. IDEM seeks comment on the affected citations listed and any other provisions of Title 329 that may be affected by this rulemaking.

First Notice of Comment Period: April 2, 2008, Indiana Register (DIN: 20080402-IR-329080209FNA).

IC 13-12-4-5 requires all state agencies to use a systematic, interdisciplinary approach to ensure integration of natural and social sciences in planning and decision-making that may impact the environment. It requires all state agencies to identify and develop methods and procedures that will ensure that unquantified environmental amenities and values be given consideration along with economic and technological considerations in decision-making. Each state agency that plans or undertakes a major state action that significantly affects the quality of the human environment is required to include a detailed statement by the responsible official that describes the environmental impact, any unavoidable adverse effects to the environment, alternatives to the proposed action, the relationship between local short-term uses of the environment and the maintenance and enhancement of long-term productivity, and any irreversible and irretrievable commitments of resources that would be involved if the proposed action is implemented. The state agency proposing the action is required to consult with and obtain comments from each state agency that has jurisdiction by law or special expertise regarding any potential environmental impact. Copies of the statement and the comments of appropriate federal, state and local agencies that are authorized to develop and enforce environmental standards shall be made available to the Governor and public and must accompany the proposal through the agency review process.

Under IC 13-12-4-5, the environmental boards are required to define in rules the actions that constitute a major state action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment.

IC 13-12-4-8 exempts state licensing and permitting actions from the requirement to develop an environmental impact statement. IC 13-12-4-10 excludes state agencies that are required to file a federal environmental impact statement under National Environmental Policy Act, 42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq. (NEPA), from the state environmental impact statement requirement.

The current rules at 329 IAC 5 provide a checklist to aid state agencies in determining whether the state action they are contemplating does in fact significantly affect the environment. Although the current rules mirror the statutory requirement that all state agencies prepare environmental impact statements for major state actions, the rules have not been beneficial in helping agencies to make such determinations. The department wants to make the rules a useful tool for developing environmental impact statements that can aid in the decision-making process for major state actions.

The current rules at 329 IAC 5 apply specifically to Indiana state agencies that plan or engage in major state actions that may have a significant impact on the environment. Those rules were intended to provide guidance and specificity to state agencies by defining the scope of analysis to which a major state action undertaken by that agency must be subjected. Those rules also set clear boundaries for the responsibility state agencies must exercise to comply with the environmental impact statement statute. The purpose of this rulemaking is to maintain that guidance and specificity, describe the scope of a major state action, and to make the guidance provided in the rule as useful as possible to state agencies that plan or undertake major state actions. A key purpose of this rulemaking is to define a "major state action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment".

The draft rule contains tools for state agencies to use to determine whether their actions rise to the level for which an environmental impact statement must be completed. Actions for which a federally-required environmental impact statement are required are exempt under Indiana law. Indiana law and this draft rule mirror federal NEPA requirements for environmental impact statements. However, the requirement to develop an environmental impact statement for state projects is a requirement imposed under Indiana law, not federal law. The requirement is a statutory requirement and not a result of this draft rule.

The draft rule does not impose any requirement or restriction on persons to whom the rule applies that is not imposed by statute under IC 13-12-4. The rule does not directly or independently impose a requirement or restriction on any person. Therefore, the rule does not impose any additional fiscal impact. The purpose of the rule is to define "major state action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment", as required by IC 13-12-4-5. The rule also provides tools that affected state agencies can use to comply with the requirements of IC 13-12-4. In accordance with IC 4-22-2-28, this rule is not anticipated to have a total estimated economic impact greater than $500,000 on all regulated entities.

An external workgroup has been established to discuss issues involved in this rulemaking. The workgroup is made up of IDEM staff and a cross-section of stakeholders. If you are interested in participating in this workgroup, or if you wish to provide comments to the workgroup on the rulemaking, attend meetings, or have suggestions related to the workgroup process, please contact Nancy King in the Office of Legal Counsel at (317) 232-7694 or (800) 451-6027 (in Indiana). Please provide your name, phone number, and e-mail address, if applicable, where you can be contacted. The public is also encouraged to submit comments and questions to members of the workgroup who represent their particular interests in the rulemaking.

IDEM requested public comment from April 2, 2008, through May 2, 2008, on alternative ways to achieve the purpose of the rule and suggestions for the development of draft rule language. IDEM received comments from the following parties by the comment period deadline:

Janet G. McCabe, Improving Kids' Environment (IKE)

Following is a summary of the comments received and IDEM's responses thereto:

Comment: IKE fully supports IDEM's effort to consider how to make the requirements of Indiana's Environmental Policy Act more effective and meaningful. IKE agrees that formation of a balanced workgroup of stakeholders is appropriate and also agrees that it makes sense to consider these requirements across the IDEM programs (air, water and land). Indiana's environmental impact review law is based on the National Environmental Policy Act; in fact, most of the language is identical to that of the federal law. It continues to be important to consider potential environmental impacts of public actions in Indiana. (IKE)

Response: IDEM concurs with this comment.

This notice requests the submission of comments on the draft rule language, including suggestions for specific revisions to language to be contained in the draft rule. Mailed comments should be addressed to:

#08-209 (SWMB) (State Environmental Policy)

Janet Pittman

Rules, Planning and Outreach Section

Office of Land Quality

Indiana Department of Environmental Management

100 North Senate Avenue, MC 66-30

Indianapolis, Indiana 46204-2251

Comments may be submitted by facsimile at the IDEM fax number: (317) 232-3403, Monday through Friday, between 8:15 a.m. and 4:45 p.m. Please confirm the timely receipt of faxed comments by calling the Rules, Planning and Outreach Section at (317) 233-1655 or (317) 232-7995.

Comments must be postmarked, faxed, or hand delivered by November 21, 2008.

Additional information regarding this action may be obtained from the Office of Land Quality by contacting Steve Mojonnier, (317) 233-1655 or Lydia Kuykendal, (317) 234-5345, or call (800) 451-6027 (in Indiana).

SECTION 1. 329 IAC 5-1-2 IS AMENDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS:

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 2. The purpose of this rule (329 IAC 5-1) article is to:

SECTION 2. 329 IAC 5-1-3 IS AMENDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS:

Affected: IC 13-12-4-8

Sec. 3. (a) This rule (329 IAC 5-1) article applies to all state agencies.

(b) Each agency of the This article does not supersede or set aside any other:

(c) IC 13-1-10-7 provides that the "(P)olicies and goals set forth in IC 13-1-10-7 and this rule (329 IAC 5-1) are supplementary to those set forth in existing authorizations of state agencies." Accordingly, each agency shall interpret the provisions of IC 13-1-10-7 and this rule (329 IAC 5-1) as a supplement to its existing authority and as a mandate to view traditional policies in the light of the chapter's (IC 13-1-10) environmental objectives.

(d) (c) Actions covered include, but are not limited to, the following:

(e) (d) Actions exempted are as follows:

(f) (e) Categorical exemptions include the following:

(g) (f) Statutory exemptions include the following:

SECTION 3. 329 IAC 5-1-4 IS AMENDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS:

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 4. (a) It is not within the scope of this rule (329 IAC 5-1) to identify before the fact which In accordance with IC 13-12-4-5, each state agency must determine whether an action it is considering constitutes a major state agency actions action significantly affect affecting the quality of the human environment. The specific determination must be developed for each agency action by preparation of Such an action requires the completion of an environmental impact statement. The definitions from this rule and the preparation of an environmental assessment as set forth in 329 IAC 5-1-5 will aid state agencies in making a determination of the necessity for an environmental impact statement. The department shall develop guidance to further aid state agencies in this assessment, including the following:

(b) Before developing an environmental impact statement, each responsible official, in preparing the assessment both primary accordance with IC 13-12-4-5, shall consult with and secondary consequences of short term and long term duration should be considered by the obtain comments of each state agency since many state actions stimulate that has jurisdiction by law or induce secondary effects in the form of associated investments special expertise with respect to any environmental impact involved. Copies of the statement and changed patterns of social the comments of the appropriate federal, state, and economic activities local agencies that are authorized to develop and enforce environmental standards:

(c) The effect of many state decisions about a project or complex of projects may be individually limited but can be cumulatively considerable in affecting the environment.

(d) A proposed action which is likely to be highly controversial from an environmental standpoint should be considered significant justification for preparation of an environmental impact statement.

SECTION 4. 329 IAC 5-3 IS ADDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS:

Affected: IC 13-11-2; IC 13-12-4

Sec. 1. The definitions in IC 13-11-2 apply throughout this article.

Affected: IC 13-11-2-51; IC 13-12-4

Sec. 2. "Department" has the meaning set forth in IC 13-11-2-51.

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 3. (a) "Environmental assessment" means a concise public document for which a state agency is responsible that does the following:

(b) An environmental assessment includes the following:

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 4. "Environmental impact statement" means the detailed written statement made by the responsible official of a state agency that plans or undertakes a major state action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment that is required by IC 13-12-4-5. The environmental impact statement describes the following:

Affected: IC 2-2.1-1; IC 4-22-2; IC 13-12-4; IC 13-14-9

Sec. 5. "Major state action" means any of the following that are planned or undertaken by a state agency:

Affected: IC 13-11-2-158; IC 13-12-4

Sec. 6. "Person" has the meaning set forth in IC 13-11-2-158(a).

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 7. "Responsible official" or "responsible state official" means the person established by law as the head of the state agency that plans or undertakes a major state action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment:

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 8. "Significantly affecting the quality of the human environment" means the following:

Affected: IC 13-12-4

Sec. 9. "State agency", as used in this article, means any:

SECTION 5. THE FOLLOWING ARE REPEALED: 329 IAC 5-1-1; 329 IAC 5-1-5; 329 IAC 5-2.

Notice of Public Hearing

DIN: 20081022-IR-329080209SNA

Composed: Apr 23,2024 4:50:15AM EDT

A PDF version of this document.